Two words: ‘advance directives’

“You cannot prevent the birds of sorrow from flying over your head, but you can prevent them from building nests in your hair.”
Old Chinese proverb

One of the most difficult questions those in the medical profession ask during a continuously deteriorating clinical scenario is, “Does XXX have any advance directives?”

What is an advance directive?

“An advance directive is a legal document that outlines your preferences for medical care if you become unable to speak or make decisions for yourself due to a serious illness, injury, or coma.”

The following are usually a form of advance directive:

  1. Living will – a written document that specifies the treatment you want or don’t want when you are terminally ill or permanently unconscious
  2. Healthcare power of attorney – a document that designates a trusted person (proxy, surrogate) to make medical decisions when on becomes incapacitated
  3. Do not resuscitate order – a specific medical order from a physician based on the wishes of the patient or family, instructing other healthcare providers NOT to perform CPR when breathing or heart beat ceases
  4. Physician/Medical orders for life-sustaining treatment – an actionable medical order that translates your advance directives to standardized instructions for emergency and medical staff

Most of the information in these will contain:

  1. Life support preferences – ventilatory support, artificial nutrition and hydration tubes (including specific medications that may or may not be vital to sustaining life)
  2. Pain management – instructions on palliative care and acceptable pain-relief medicines
  3. Resuscitation – whether to do CPR or defibrillation
  4. Additional wishes – organ or tissue donation, and other religious or spiritual care when the time comes

I write about this as I see patients whose parents or friends and relatives who when I need to address their medical concerns, have difficulty in discussing the topic of advance directives.

I personally feel that this is something each and every one of us must make while many of us still have our mental faculties intact. While it is a topic that many Filipinos refuse to discuss, it is one whose time has come. Rather than discussing issues on Artificial Intelligence or the latest gadgets available or political turmoil or the economy, or even healthcare costs and benefits, I strongly feel that advance directive is an important conversation every physician must make with those they care for, especially those who are critically and chronically ill.

It protects personal autonomy by ensuring that our personal beliefs, values and wishes are honored even when you are unable to make decisions for yourself anymore.

It relieves family burden when having to make critical end-of-life decisions as this places a lot of stress, guilt and agonizing ‘what if’ moments to loved ones.

It reduces family conflicts who eventually disagree on the treatment of an incapacitated family member. Placing explicit instructions in writing to a proxy helps alleviate this confrontation.

It guides healthcare providers on the actionable boundaries on whether to aggressively intervene or focus on providing comfort and aligning with best care plan with patient goals.

It prevents unwanted or over-aggressive care. Prolonged, painful, or unwanted medical procedures in permanent or terminal conditions result in unnecessary emotional and financial costs to the family and to the healthcare system.

There is no easy way to discuss this with patients but it is a conversation that must be brought up with empathy, clarity and sensitivity.

Aside from these, it’s always good advice to colleagues to:

  • Choose calm settings – speak in private, quiet room, away from public and loud places
  • Validate the stress the family or loved ones are going through now. Acknowledge that the current setting is overwhelming and that there is some news or update that may not be good and that while it is difficult to impart, it needs to be said and everyone needs to be more prepared.
  • Frame it around the patient’s voice. It’s not about YOU. It’s about the patient. The goal is to honor what the patient would have wanted and not place the burden of choice on the family.
  • Involve other specialists when needed – a priest, social worker, or palliative care team to join the conversation especially if the family is struggling to process the medical updates.

I’ve done this playbook several times and it’s really never easy to talk about grief when the person is still physically here with you. The compassion and empathy must be there when you share the bad and sad news.

There is never a painless goodbye.